Delayed trains, obsolete N-network: Germany's rail crisis

Sophie Renassia
Written by Sophie Renassia
Published on July 3, 2025, modified on November 13, 2026
Delayed trains, obsolete N-network: Germany's rail crisis

If someone asked you to name a country whose trains are often late,, you might first think of France? It must be said that SNCF is quite often criticized by the French for its delays and cancellations. The chairman of the SNCF group himself sounded the alarm on our podcast about the need for the State to invest in maintaining the French rail network, an essential condition for guaranteeing the reliability of our public service.

Yet one of France's neighbors is a much worse performer: Germany. Breakdowns, delays, cancellations… In recent years, Deutsche Bahn (DB), once a benchmark of punctuality and efficiency, has lost its shine. Worse, it is now going through such a crisis that the Swiss Federal Railways no longer allow German trains running more than 15 minutes late to enter Basel station. In total, Germany has accumulated more than €35 billion in debt and an investment backlog estimated at €150 billion to restore and develop its network. And according to Jean-Pierre Farandou (then CEO of SNCF), the French network could well face the same fate if nothing changes*.

You will have understood: Germany, once a rail model, is now in crisis. How did it come to this, and what can France learn from it? We investigated to understand what tipped one of Europe's largest rail networks into chaos. And spoiler: it's not just a question of budget.

Update from November 13, 2026

Good news: the situation has evolved in France since this article was published. Following the conclusions of the Ambition France Transports conference (July 2025), the State and SNCF Réseau signed a performance contract on November 12, 2026, bringing investments in the network to €4.5 billion per year starting in 2028, €1.5 billion more than today. However, the funding is not yet fully secured. More info later in the article and in our explainer:

SNCF Réseau Performance Contract: What This Means for Train Service

Article

SNCF Réseau Performance Contract: What This Means for Train Service

The Golden Age and the Fall: From Reform to Disillusionment

A Promising Legacy and an Ambitious Reform

To understand the decline of German rail, we need to go back to 1994, the year of the great reform of German rail. When the Berlin Wall fell in 1990, reunified Germany had to make two completely different rail systems coexist. In the West, the Deutsche Bundesbahn, a public behemoth already drowning in debt. In the East, the Deutsche Reichsbahn, an even more decrepit socialist network.

Thus, in 1994, Deutsche Bahn AG was born — a private company but 100% state-owned — from the merger of the networks east and west. The goal: combine private-sector efficiency with public oversight. Thanks to the State, which wiped out the colossal debt accumulated up to that point (more than €30 billion in debt!), a fresh start becomes possible.

Initially, this reform bore fruit, with an improvement in punctuality(over 90% punctuality in the 1990s-2000s) and a modernization of the network. The model is unprecedented and seems to be working: a public company that operates like a private one, with a logic of partial privatization. But it is precisely this hybrid structure, half public, half private, that will soon cause serious problems.

Also read: Great Britain: From Privatization to Renationalization of the Network

The Roots of the Evil: Profitability at Any Cost

But as early as the 2000s, while the Die Bahn brand dusts off the image of rail and even expands internationally, problems pile up behind the scenes. The cause? Quickly, cost reduction is made the priority, sometimes at the expense of long-term vision.

Since 1994, more than 5,400 km of railway lines have been eliminated, that is nearly a sixth of the network, dropping from about 44,600 km in 1994 to less than 40,000 km today. This contraction of the network has been accompanied by the elimination of railway workers' jobs and the outsourcing of many activities.

While the DB was supposed to be profitable while providing a public service, the public-private hybrid model creates contradictions. The lack of transparency in the use of public funds, often reinvested internally without any real accountability, exacerbates the situation.

Decline of Deutsche Bahn: How Did It Come to This?

The State's Withdrawal and Misdirected Investments

From the very beginning, the 1994 reform carried a contradiction within it: the DB was asked to behave like a private company, with profitability targets, while continuing to provide a public service on a vast network that is expensive to maintain. In other words, it was expected to turn a profit while transporting everyone, everywhere, all the time.

Gradually, the government withdraws from rail financing, hoping the private sector will step in. But while Deutsche Bahn AG was initially meant to be privatized, the 2008 financial crisis interrupted this process, and the German state still holds 100% of the shares today. And as we will see, this ambivalence of partial privatization has generated numerous contradictions in its strategic management.

The DB is also required to pay dividends to the state and invests massively in costly international projects at the expense of its national network. The result? Massive debt.

Economic Choices That Plunge the Network into Paralysis

At the same time, everyone wants "more with less" (fewer trains in reserve, fewer drivers available, less room for maneuver, fewer specialized engineers), there is no longer any "safety net": the slightest grain of sand triggers cascading train cancellations. The savings also hit maintenance: certain preventive operations, deemed too costly, are scaled back. For example, less sand is put into sandboxes in autumn (which helps trains brake) or heating of switches is limited in winter. Changes that seem minor, but with very real consequences, since they cause more seasonal breakdowns and more delays.

In 2009, German rail goes through a major crisis: more than half of trains are canceled. The cause? A large part of the fleet is indeed judged dangerous (due to lack of maintenance): brakes and wheels are worn out and the equipment is out of compliance. The DB is then forced to pay compensation to the State of Berlin and seriously damages its reputation. This is one of the perverse effects of partial privatization: to save money, maintenance is reduced to the bare minimum, even at the cost of compromising passenger safety.

In the 2010s, infrastructure starts to seriously saturate and punctuality collapses, falling below the 70% mark on some major lines. In 2015, the DB finally tries to react with a plan dubbed "Future of Rail." But it quickly becomes clear how extensive the damage is, and decades of underinvestment drag the DB into a vicious cycle. In the 2020s, people talk outright about the collapse of German rail. Richard Lutz, one of the DB's executives, speaks of "the worst crisis since the 1994 reform." In 2023, barely 62.5% of long-distance trains arrive on time.

Runaway management and doctored statistics

DB's leadership saw more and more finance professionals replacing railway experts. To hide the delays, DB even resorted to the "Pofalla maneuver": canceling trains rather than declaring them late to artificially inflate the punctuality statistics.

Another absurdity: a fine system is supposed to force Deutsche Bahn to act. For example, if it is supposed to repair bridges in poor condition and doesn't, it must pay a €15 million fine. But since paying a €15 million fine is often much cheaper than carrying out real works (€300 million to repair a single bridge in Cologne), Deutsche Bahn sometimes prefers to deliberately let the infrastructure deteriorate.

Aging infrastructure, speed restrictions and saturated hubs… Today, the German rail network is exhausted, literally "worked to the point of wear and tear" in the very words of the Court of Auditors.

German Trains: Lessons and Prospects for France

The German Lesson

The German experience highlights the importance of solid governance and a clear strategic vision. The Deutsche Bahn (DB) found itself in an ambiguous position, oscillating between a subsidized public company and a private actor with no real oversight, making responsibilities blurry and encouraging the buck-passing between the state and management: is it the government's fault for cutting budgets, DB's fault for not knowing how to manage them, or a hybrid model that seems impossible to control?

Today, a debate is shaking the country: should DB be dismantled? Should it be fully renationalized, as Great Britain did? Should the rails be separated from the trains? Nothing has been decided. Fortunately, this situation is finally starting to be taken seriously: Transport Minister Volker Wissing announced a historic investment plan of €86 billion by 2029, of which €45 billion specifically dedicated to the modernization of rail infrastructure by 2027. This funding will be partially covered by an increase in the heavy goods vehicle tax, marking a strategic shift in favor of rail, and is part of a broader €500 billion economic recovery plan.

Toward a German Rail Renaissance?

This investment plan aims to transform the network: thousands of kilometers of tracks, bridges and facilities will be renovated, signaling will be modernized and tracks electrified. Temporary line closures are even planned for deep renovations, limiting long-term disruptions. In parallel, Olaf Scholz's government has launched major structural reforms. DB will refocus on its core business by divesting subsidiaries like DB Schenker and DB Arriva to lighten its debt. A new entity, DB Infra, will be created to manage the rails and stations on a non-profit and transparent basis, reinvesting all of its profits in network maintenance. Concrete measures are also being put in place for users, including hiring technicians, installing fault-detection sensors and optimizing connections.

Despite everything, the DB turnaround looks complex, and user trust will be hard to win back. The modernization of a network of nearly 40,000 km while keeping it running represents a titanic challenge, inevitably causing short-term disruptions. Will Germany be able to become a benchmark again in sustainable, reliable and high-performing rail transport, thereby encouraging the modal shift from road to rail for passengers and freight? Stay tuned…

And France: how to avoid the same scenario?

The German example raises a crucial question for France: has the SNCF managed to avoid the same pitfalls? While the models and histories of the two countries diverge, similarities emerge in their dysfunctions. The 1997 reform of the SNCF, aimed at separating network management (RFF) from the operator, did not produce the expected results. Underfunded, RFF was unable to prevent the deterioration of the conventional network, while the SNCF prioritized the success of the TGV.

Today, the average age of French tracks exceeds 30 years, many small lines are abandoned, and speed restrictions for safety reasons are multiplying, with average speeds sometimes laughably low on certain regional lines. The French Court of Auditors in fact highlighted in 2021 a growing debt due to insufficient public funding.

Although the French situation is not yet as critical as in Germany, thanks in particular to the technological and commercial showcase of the TGV and its good punctuality, the French conventional network (TER and INTERCITÉS) suffers from ills comparable to those of the German network. We find the same chronic underinvestment, a heavy dependence on regional subsidies, frequent delays, and aging rolling stock.

Ultimately, France and Germany share the risk of rail decline if decisive measures are not taken. Despite shared strengths such as high-speed rail, the extent of their networks, and cutting-edge engineering, both countries also face the same adversary: the powerful automobile and road lobby, which has often held back rail funding. As the German Court of Auditors points out, the fundamental question remains whether railways should be oriented toward profit or the common good.

Updated November 13, 2026

On July 9, 2025, the Minister of Transport announced an additional €1.5 billion per year for the network starting in 2028, a move hailed at the time by Jean-Pierre Farandou. It is now official: the performance contract signed on November 12, 2026 between the State and SNCF Réseau raises these investments to €4.5 billion per year starting in 2028. The funding still needs to be secured: the SNCF group is contributing €500 million per year, and the rest depends largely on the 2027 budget and the framework law on transport, still under discussion in Parliament. And still nothing, meanwhile, on the tax breaks for air travel… To learn more: our full analysis.

Ultimately, the story of the decline of the Deutsche Bahn is as troubling as it is instructive. It demonstrates that a rail network can rapidly deteriorate without investment and long-term vision, even in a developed country. It also highlights the essential levers for a robust rail system: sustained funding, clear governance, a strong operational culture, and a focus on the public interest.

In France, the State committed at the end of 2026 to invest an additional €1.5 billion per year in the network starting in 2028: the challenge is to guarantee that funding over time. Let's hope the DB crisis continues to remind us of the value of rail. As noted by former SNCF Group Chairman Jean-Pierre Farandou, the train is “a common good bequeathed to us by our ancestors”, a collective legacy it is our responsibility to pass on in good health to future generations.

Sophie Renassia
Written by Sophie Renassia

Issue du monde de la communication et des médias, Sophie est Responsable éditoriale chez HOURRAIL ! depuis août 2024. Elle est notamment derrière le contenu éditorial du site ainsi que La Locomissive (de l'inspiration voyage bas carbone et des bons plans, un jeudi sur deux, gratuitement dans ta boîte mail !).

Convaincue que les changements d’habitude passent par la transformation de nos imaginaires, elle s’attache à montrer qu’il est possible de voyager autrement, de manière plus consciente, plus lente et plus joyeuse. Son objectif : rendre le slow travel accessible à toutes et tous, à travers des astuces, des décryptages et surtout, de nouveaux récits.

Related articles

cookie-logo
How do we process your data?
We use cookies to improve your browsing experience and personalize our content. They are mainly used for statistical purposes.