Why is the train more expensive than the plane? Alexis Chailloux's analysis

Sophie Renassia
Written by Sophie Renassia
Published on April 5, 2025, modified on November 13, 2026
Why is the train more expensive than the plane? Alexis Chailloux's analysis

“Trains are way too expensive in France!” It's a remark you hear often, and it sparks debate. But what do our tickets actually pay for? Why such price gaps compared with flying? Why do prices vary so much from one moment to the next? And, ultimately, what's really at stake behind our tickets?

To shed some light, we wanted to give the floor to several experts in French rail whose viewpoints and interests diverge, through a four-part series on our podcast Je t’offre un rail?. In this first episode, we bring you the analysis of Alexis Chailloux, transport lead for the NGO Réseau Action Climat (which brings together associations committed to fighting climate disruption) and member of the collective Itinéraire Bis (which works to transform media representations of travel).

What do our tickets pay for?

A heavy and costly infrastructure

Trains rely on a vast and complex infrastructure that requires colossal investment for its upkeep and modernization. " The older a network is, the more incidents there will be, or at the very least traffic restrictions", explains Alexis Chailloux. For example, there is no direct train from Saint-Étienne to Clermont because the line has been gradually abandoned!

" The regeneration and modernization of the network are absolutely essential for the functioning of the French train. But this regeneration and modernization cost a great deal." - Alexis Chailloux

Unlike aviation, which benefits from airports depreciated over the long term and a relatively free airspace, rail involves kilometers of track that must be maintained daily. In France, network maintenance costs around €5 billion a year, shared largely between SNCF and the state. Each kilometer of high-speed line (LGV) requires an initial investment of €15 to €30 million, on top of which come maintenance costs of up to €100,000 per kilometer per year. "Right now, there is a shortfall of at least €1.5 billion a year to ensure the modernization of the network", notes Alexis Chaillaux.

Update (November 2026): the performance contract signed on November 12, 2026 between the state and SNCF Réseau provides for exactly €1.5 billion more per year for the regeneration and modernization of the network starting in 2028. Their funding still needs to be secured. More info in our dedicated article. 👈

When this maintenance is neglected, the consequences can be very heavy for travelers. The German trains are proof of that, recording numerous delays due to a lack of foresight in anticipating the aging of the network, and many worksites underway…

Rail

Not to mention the costs linked to ancillary infrastructure: stations, signaling, rolling stock...

An economic model based on track access charges

To understand better, we need to go back to the different players in the French railway system:

  • TER: regional transport, managed and subsidized by the regions (more than 50% of the ticket price covered, but only for rolling stock and not for the network).
  • INTERCITÉS: managed by the state, which bears part of the costs but also passes track access charges on to tickets.
  • Train à Grande Vitesse (TGV): whose technical term is "SLO", for "Service librement organisé" (freely organized service), since it is fully open to competition (beyond SNCF Voyageurs, foreign companies like Renfe and Trenitalia can position themselves on the segment of their choice), and not subsidized by the state. Operators therefore pay a significant share of railway track access charges.

These different trains run on the rail network managed by SNCF Réseau, a subsidiary of the SNCF group (which is independent of SNCF Voyageurs and allocates track slots to the various rail companies, and must even favor new entrants).

Network operations and maintenance are funded both:

- by the railway toll system ("like on the highway, where you pay for the service you use by car", explains Alexis Chailloux),

- and in part by the state through the AFIT (Transport Infrastructure Financing Agency) and the profits of the SNCF Group (for example, part of the profits from the freight carrier Géodis are reinvested in the network).

Unlike highways, where tolls are paid directly by drivers, rail companies must therefore pay hefty fees to use the tracks. In France, these rail tolls amount on average to €9.50 per kilometer traveled for a high-speed train. These fees weigh heavily in the economics of rail, and they are passed on directly or indirectly to ticket prices.

By the way, don't hesitate to sign the petition launched by our association (Les Aventuriers d'HOURRAIL!) calling for lower rail tolls!

Why does the train cost so much?

Dynamic pricing (yield management)

You've probably already noticed that the later you book your ticket, the more the price tends to climb. After all, we often remind you of this golden rule in our newsletter: to pay less, the earlier the better.

Train tickets are not set at a single fare. This "yield management" strategy, borrowed from the airline industry, consists of adjusting prices in real time based on demand thanks to dynamic pricing algorithms. The higher the demand, the more prices rise, which penalizes last-minute travelers.

For example, a Paris-Lyon TGV trip can cost €30 if you book weeks in advance, and exceed €150 during peak periods or if you book the day before. For many travelers, this variability reinforces a sense of unfairness, especially when you don't have the flexibility to plan far in advance.

SNCF Connect interface

The tax imbalance compared to air travel

Another factor explaining the high cost of train travel is the taxation applied to it. In France, VAT on train tickets is set at 10%, while the aviation sector enjoys two major tax exemptions: no tax on kerosene, and 0% VAT on international flights (10% on domestic flights)! "This asymmetry indirectly favors air travel at the expense of trains, an ecological and economic absurdity", laments Alexis Chailloux.

"Flying Strasbourg-Berlin, you pay 0% VAT. Yet taking the train from Strasbourg to Berlin, you pay 10% of the ticket price in VAT. That makes no sense!"

Since March 2025, the solidarity tax on plane tickets in France (also called the "Chirac tax") has increased. In practice, its amount, which was negligible, will rise slightly (from €2.63 to €7.40 for a European flight).

This increase should bring in €800 to €850 million for the state. But as Alexis Chailloux points out in a LinkedIn post, this remains still far from what a kerosene tax would bring in, since the aviation sector enjoys a considerable tax advantage (zero tax on kerosene)... "Why would kerosene escape taxation while gasoline doesn't? Why would vacationing on the other side of the world be VAT-exempt when even basic necessities are subject to it (at a reduced rate)?" he regrets in his post.

Airplane taking off

In his view, rebalancing taxes would therefore make trains more competitive without necessarily increasing public subsidies.

Opening up to competition: magic solution or mirage?

"We tend to think, in every sector, that liberalization and opening up to competition will be more efficient than public service", notes Alexis Chailloux. And the arrival of new players in the French rail market, such as Trenitalia or Renfe, does indeed hint at a possible price drop due to competition: "Competition has had positive effects on certain routes, such as the Paris-Lyon route, where supply increased with companies like Trenitalia, and therefore a slight drop in the average ticket price."

But the downsides are numerous: "It has also had plenty of negative side effects, such as a commercial war between the incumbent companies. For example, the arrival of an OUIGO (French) on the Madrid-Barcelona line in Spain had consequences for cooperation with Spain (which now requires French drivers to have Spanish skills on certain slots)."

In some countries like Italy, where several companies already operate on high-speed lines, prices have indeed dropped on contested routes. Since the government took on part of the tolls, the cost for rail companies was lower, which stimulated offers (and allowed the state to recoup its "investment").

But let's also mention the example of the (total) privatization of British rail, which we tell you about in detail here, which, far from bringing prices down, actually led to exorbitant fares and ended in a U-turn!

To go further: the proposals of the Adventurers of HOURRAIL! (the low-carbon travel enthusiasts' association) to decarbonize transport, notably by reducing the cost of train travel.

As you've probably gathered, lowering the price of train travel isn't so straightforward. Some leads: a genuine political will — to reform taxation and invest in the maintenance and modernization of the network — better regulation of pricing to avoid the price gaps that penalize last-minute travelers, a rebalancing between air and rail transport seems key to making trains more attractive... Either way, the future of rail transport will depend on the strategic choices made today and on the ability of public authorities to reconcile profitability and accessibility!

To follow all the latest news from Réseau Action Climat, you can follow the NGO on social media (and especially on Instagram). The NGO will soon be releasing two reports, one on night train travel and one on the structure of a train ticket (vs. a plane ticket).

To make sure you don't miss any of our upcoming deep dives and get all the best low-carbon travel deals, don't hesitate to subscribe to our newsletter (every other Thursday in your inbox):

Our best train deals, straight to your inbox

Inspiration and great deals for your next low-carbon trips

Every 2 weeks1-click unsubscribe
Sophie Renassia
Written by Sophie Renassia

Issue du monde de la communication et des médias, Sophie est Responsable éditoriale chez HOURRAIL ! depuis août 2024. Elle est notamment derrière le contenu éditorial du site ainsi que La Locomissive (de l'inspiration voyage bas carbone et des bons plans, un jeudi sur deux, gratuitement dans ta boîte mail !).

Convaincue que les changements d’habitude passent par la transformation de nos imaginaires, elle s’attache à montrer qu’il est possible de voyager autrement, de manière plus consciente, plus lente et plus joyeuse. Son objectif : rendre le slow travel accessible à toutes et tous, à travers des astuces, des décryptages et surtout, de nouveaux récits.

cookie-logo
How do we process your data?
We use cookies to improve your browsing experience and personalize our content. They are mainly used for statistical purposes.